What do you do when your product is a massive fail, and consumers openly say it is horrid? If you are Domino’s Pizza, you boldly embrace the criticism. And, you create a microsite (PizzaTurnaround.com) as a platform to document the change.
On the cusp of its 50th birthday, Domino’s Pizza has put out a new campaign owning up to a product that many people really didn’t like. (In a survey, Domino’s Pizza tied for last place for taste …with Chuck E Cheese. Ouch!) The new “Pizza Turnaround” video was created by powerhouse agency Crispin Porter + Bogusky.
In the four-minute video focus group members said repeatedly that the crust is like cardboard. Other pizza flavour insights include “totally void of flovour” and “the worst excuse for pizza I’ve ever had”.
Exactly. You have to give Domino’s kudos for their humility and transparent approach. The company is taking wonderful, brutally honest step forward, trying to reclaim its image.
But back to the microsite. How does it fare as a content channel?
It’s got the usual social network links to Facebook and Twitter (which are both great examples of social media use and interaction). However, the microsite lacks an RSS feed and a link to their YouTube channel. And, while they have a small members-only Flickr group for employees, there is no group for us, the hoi polloi.
You have to give Domino’s high credit for bringing in a feed from Twitter, and not filtering the results. Many of the comments weren’t exactly shining examples of brand love when I was there. But, bravo for showing the comments – warts and all. It boosts credibility and authenticity.
In addition to driving traffic to the site from Twitter or the Domino's
homepage, traffic from natural search queries should never be
overlooked. From a search point of view, it would have been nice to see
the microsite appear in more niche searches like “Domino’s Pizza taste”
or “Domino’s Pizza crust”. (It does currently rank #9 for “new Domino’s
Pizza”.) And, I’d love to see the banner text rendered as readable type
to search engines rather than a graphic.
I don’t know if the microsite creates any extra value. Users need to click through to the Domino’s pizza site to order, find a nearby location or get a coupon. While comments are allowed, there is little other way to interact or create content on the site. For example, have Domino's customers create a new tagline for the pizza, or upload their own experiences which could be shared.
Will the commitment to a better product continue on with the microsite, or will it have a limited shelf-life and eventually fade away? If there is a long-term commitment to better taste and a better product, why not incorporate it into the main Domino’s Pizza website?
The site is no doubt a work in progress and it will be interesting to watch how it evolves.
Google Local Business: Why Customer Reviews Matter - 12.01.09
The other day I was having a series of conversations with some friends about Montreal restaurants – the good, the bad and the downright pretentious. As a lark, I googled “pretentious restaurant Montreal” expecting to get blog rants, various foodie forum discussions and the like. (I did.) But, imagine my surprise when Google Local Business listing served up some pretentious restaurants for my viewing pleasure.
What?
I understood the location-based aspect of the Local Business result, but surely, the restaurants weren’t entering “pretentious” in as some of their keywords for the business listing description? I suspected it was tied to the reviews that were being pulled in. But best to try this again just to make sure. How about “worst restaurant in Montreal”? Why, yes, once again Google Local Business pulls through.
The race was on.
How about "worst customer service Toronto”? Bingo!
Interestingly, they were all hotels. I assumed it was because travel review sites are so popular. More reviews = more skew. Testing my theory I tried “worst customer service Vancouver”. Once again, all hotels with the exception of one bike shop that had incurred the wrath of four reviewers.
Companies take warning: This is the power of consumer-generated reviews. Right now it’s a high concentration of hotels, restaurants and travel. But as user-generated content continues to grow, it will influence your ranking - not only for the keywords you used, but for other unintended keyword queries. More than ever, companies need to monitor what is being said about them so they can address service issues and correct the problem at the source.
It's hard to believe that the myth of the keyword meta tag still exists, but it does. And now Google has taken a firm stance, stating in no uncertain terms "Google does not use the keywords meta tag in web ranking." So, it's official. Don't bother with the keyword meta tag.
Yesterday I was having a conversation with a friend who asked if Twitter was good for optimization purposes. My answer was the wonderfully ambiguous, “Well, yes and no.”
We’ll start with the no part.
Twitter, like many other social media sites, adds a “nofollow” attribute to all outbound links. Google, Yahoo and MSN exclude links listed as “nofollow” links from their algorithmic calculations. One of the few search engines that ignores the “nofollow” command is Ask.com, which has a small part of the search engine market share. So, try as you may, linking to your site or your blog will not increase your number of incoming links.
But all is not lost.
In an interview at WebProNews, Joe Whyte said, “I tend to think that link value is still passed but at a much lower value. We also know that these links do get picked up and put into Google's and Yahoo's backlink checker and we know that nofollow still allows spiders to cache and index, which is still great.”
And yesterday, things got even better as Twitter's new VP of Operations, Santosh Jayaram, who incidentally was VP of Search Quality for Google, announced that Twitter will soon be crawling and indexing links.
This means Twitter will go beyond tracking conversations and enter a new phase of real-time search. As well, Twitter Search will get “get a reputation ranking system. That means that not all tweets will be equal; rank will be calculated for each twitterer, probably based on several criteria such as number of followers, number of retweets and so forth.” (From Mashable)
I suspect that just as Google uses domain age, no doubt length of Twitter use will play a part as well.
It’s a very exciting and potentially huge development.
The bottom line is brand recognition and visibility. You can use Twitter to create community and share your latest post. The site visitors can then share and bookmark your post through Sphinn, Buzz Up, StumbleUpon or any other number of tools. Additionally, as you build your community, “RTs” (retweets) help spread and maximize your message, getting it out to more and more audiences. And don’t forget that Twitter has just become an even better resource for keyword research. Use it to better understand your market and what they are looking for.
If you are looking at Twitter from a pure Google PageRank angle, no it is not going to help with optimization… but going beyond and looking at how interactions with your community can help create a more solid relationship with your potential customers and attract people to your website, then Twitter is fantastic for optimizing your site.
This is one of my favourite quotes this week, “Not all marketing stories are literal; be aware of the story told through your site design choices.” Read this outstanding article by David Rossiter that reflects on storytelling, user-friendly design and the social web.
Are you a B2B marketer? Gord Hotchkiss has authored a white paper titled “Mapping the BuyerSphere” in which he examines different buyer roles, the identified risk control mechanisms, and the relative effect of a vendor's credibility and positioning. You can download it here.
Mitch Joel offers his insights on speaking in a powerful new way as part of Cluetrain Manifesto's 10th anniversary. Read other posts expanding on Cluetrain’s tenets at Cluetrainplus10.
Friday Fun Twitter Magnets – Don’t say I didn’t warn you – it’s addictive!
Kathryn from Zoonini and I would love to thank everyone who has enjoyed and shared our public service announcement Do I Need a Flash Intro? We got over 50,000 unique visitors in 4 days from over 130 countries. Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU!
Don’t get us wrong – we love Flash, when it’s used correctly to inspire, inform and engage your site visitors. It can create a slick, professional look. But a Flash intro is the equivalent of trying to bulldoze your visitor with a commercial about you, you, you. (Usually with bad techno music - the horror!) And, to boot, a Flash intro can be counterproductive to any web site optimization.
Your website isn’t about imposing YOUR experience. It’s about building a compelling, informative experience. If you are thinking about a Flash intro ask yourself this:
Does the Flash intro interfere with my visitor’s ability to access the information they are looking for?
Flash intros create a block between your great content and your potential customer’s to access it. Why would you want to do that?
One of the biggest stories this week was Dominos. And the above search results are just a small example how not having a social media plan in place can be damaging. After employees behaved very badly indeed, and uploaded their food pranks to YouTube, things went sideways for the pizza chain. USA Today explains some of the lessons to be learned.
Well, Digg released a URL shortener that failed to impress. (That’s being kind.) Read the Truth About Digg’s DiggBar to get the inside scoop on why it’s just plain evil from an SEO point-of-view. Gene Smith offers up a few alternative options.
What’s wrong with the phrase “social media”? Josh Bernoff elegantly explains Why 'Social Media' Sucks.
Kelowna’s Orchard Park Shopping Mall hit one out of the park with its “Fresh-er-vention” Facebook contest. I foresee more Facebook Connect campaigns, don't you?
Not to sound all gushy, but Lee Odden is an SEO rock star. He continually puts out Top 10 material. Read his article Improve Public Relations with SEO & Social Media, and discover why keyword research, content optimization and content assets can add value to your website, your end user and your company’s brand.
Who doesn’t love a makeover? Roberta Rosenberg does a brilliant job of explaining how TheWeddingLens.com could be improved and get a better conversion rate.